- SAVE 5%
- SAVE 10%
6-Jar Bundle
- SAVE 20 %
12-Jar Bundle
Text a real human
Not AI, a real person from our team. We typically reply within a few minutes.
Questions? Text Us!By texting us, you agree to receive SMS messages. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Terms & Privacy Policy
Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard
Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard
Couldn't load pickup availability
90-Day Money-Back Guarantee
Text a real human
Not AI, a real person from our team. We typically reply within a few minutes.
Questions? Text Us!By texting us, you agree to receive SMS messages. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Terms & Privacy Policy
Why buy Hatch Chile Sauces?
Flame Roasted
No Dried or Dehydrated Pods
No Sugar Added
No Preservatives
- SAVE 5%
3-Jar Bundle
- SAVE 10%
6-Jar Bundle
- SAVE 20 %
12-Jar Bundle
Text a real human
Not AI, a real person from our team. We typically reply within a few minutes.
Questions? Text Us!By texting us, you agree to receive SMS messages. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Terms & Privacy Policy
Product Description
Product Description
Fresh Chile's Sweet & Spicy Mustard is made with Hatch Chile & #1-grade mustard seeds. We made this classic style mustard to complement the flavor of Hatch Chile and the result is sweet & spicy mustard that is sure to become a household favorite. Continue the family tradition of Hatch Chile and create a taste in your next dish that your friends & family will love.
Ingredients: Hatch Chile, Premium Prepared Mustard (Distilled Vinegar, Water, #1 Grade Mustard Seeds, Salt, Turmeric, Paprika Spices), Sugar, Onion, Fresh Pickle Relish, Apple Cider Vinegar, Garlic, Rice Flour, Crushed Red Pepper Salt.
Shipping & Returns
Shipping & Returns
At Fresh Chile, we aim to deliver your favorite flavors quickly and hassle-free.
Shipping:
• Orders are typically processed within 1-2 business days.
• Free shipping is available for All Access Members on rates up to $20 (US only).
• Standard shipping rates apply to non-members based on weight and location.
Returns & Refunds:
• Your satisfaction is our priority! If you’re not 100% happy with your order, contact us within 30 days for a replacement or refund.
• Items must be unopened and in their original condition to qualify for a return.
For any questions or assistance, reach out to us at service@freshchileco.com or call 575-800-8284.

As Featured in Cowboy Kent Rollins' Cooking Video
So fresh, so authentic. that’s what it is. So much flavor in a spoonful.
Cowboy Kent Rollins, Cook
Over 3M Subscribers on YouTube
Featured Hatch Chile Recipes
-
Grilled Eggplant with Hatch Jalapeños Recipe
AppetizerDifficulty: EasyTotal Time: 4-6 hours -
Hatch Red Chile Deviled Eggs Recipe
AppetizerDifficulty: EasyTotal Time: 20-30 mins -
Hatch Red Chile Posole
AppetizerDifficulty: EasyTotal Time: 20-30 mins -
Hatch Red Chile Honey Wings Recipe
AppetizerDifficulty: EasyTotal Time: 20-30 mins -
Hatch Red Chile Carne Adovada
AppetizerDifficulty: EasyTotal Time: 20-30 mins
90-Day Money Back Guarantee
We stand by a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee Policy for our chile products. If you are not completely satisfied, reach out to us to get your full refund.
This Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chili Mustard is some really good stuff! I'm not much for straight mustard on anything, but this combo of sweet relish, the Hatch Chiles and the mustard makes a combo that I'll eat on just about everything. Grilled & fried chicken breasts, burgers, hotdogs, brats, even pork tenderloin. It's a quality product. We've used almost the entire jar in just the short time since we received the shipment. Time to order MORE! Saw this product being used on my favorite Cowboy Cooking show -- Ken Rollins.
If you haven't tried this Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard, get yourself some soon!! As I said in a previous review for the Hatch Ketchup (Hatchup) we're "Hooked on Hatch" in Houston, PA & that goes for this mustard as well. Try a jar & I know you'll be too!! Thanks Fresh Chili Company for making such high quality, delicious products!!
Hi there,
Thank you for taking the time to leave such a wonderful review for our Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard. We are thrilled to hear that you are enjoying the combination of sweet relish, Hatch Chiles, and mustard in this product. We also love that you have found so many delicious ways to use it in your meals.
We are honored to have been featured on your favorite Cowboy Cooking show and we are glad to hear that you are 'Hooked on Hatch' in Houston, PA. We appreciate your support and are happy to hear that we have made a high-quality and delicious product that you love.
Thank you again for your kind words and for being a valued customer. We hope you continue to enjoy our Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard and all of our other Hatch products.
Best regards,
The Fresh Chili Company Team
Love it beside the normal mustard venues have been using it on crab cakes
Thank you for your review! We're so happy to hear that you love our Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard and have found new ways to enjoy it. Using it on crab cakes sounds delicious! Thank you for sharing your experience with us.
10/10.The mustard is awesome.
Thank you for the glowing review! We're so happy to hear that you loved our Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard. Your satisfaction is our top priority and we're thrilled to receive a 10/10 rating. Thank you for choosing our product and we hope you continue to enjoy it!
Really like the flavor, but there are really a lot of big chunks of onion.
Thank you for your feedback on our Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard. We are glad to hear that you enjoy the flavor. We apologize for the chunks of onion, we will certainly take note of this and work on improving the consistency. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
Great product with the chiles and mustard, would like to try one with a little less sugar. But thank you very much.
Thank you for your review! We're glad to hear that you enjoyed our Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard with its unique blend of chiles and mustard. We appreciate your feedback and will definitely take into consideration your request for a version with less sugar. We hope you continue to enjoy our products. Thank you for your support!
Join 31,000+ Members in Our Cooking Group
By joining our Fresh Chile Cookin' Facebook Group, you can:
- Explore new and exciting Hatch Chile recipes, creatively shared by a community of over 31,000 members.
- Gain valuable cooking tips and inspiration from fellow Hatch Chile enthusiasts.
- Engage in meaningful conversations and form connections within a vibrant Hatch Chile community.
Shop Other Chile Varieties
Choose Your Perfect Heat Level
Our Hatch chiles come in four distinct heat levels to cater to every palate:
-
Mild
A gentle introduction to Hatch chiles, offering a subtle warmth that doesn't overpower. Ideal for those who prefer a milder spice experience.
Scoville Heat Units: 500
-
Medium
A balanced heat that provides a noticeable kick without being overwhelming. Perfect for those who enjoy a moderate level of spiciness.
Scoville Heat Units: 2500
-
Hot
For the spice enthusiasts, this level brings a robust and lively heat to your dishes. Great for those who love a fiery flavor.
Scoville Heat Units: 5000
-
Xtra Hot
Our most intense option, delivering a powerful and lasting heat. Recommended for the bravest of spice lovers.
Scoville Heat Units: 15,000
-
Your choice should reflect your personal taste and spice tolerance. If you're new to Hatch chiles, you might want to start with Mild or Medium. As you become more accustomed to the heat, you might find yourself gravitating towards Hot or Xtra Hot. Remember, everyone's spice threshold is different, so choose what makes your taste buds happy!